Department of DoubtForm 366: Three polls instead of one decision, declined

"A judgement call": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it

"A judgement call" is the decision nobody else can make for you: no rule covers it, so someone has to look at it and choose. A team lead was asked to make a judgement call on whether the Friday meeting could be skipped this week. Instead, they set up a poll. Then a follow-up poll about the first poll. Then a third poll on which poll should count. On Friday the team met for forty minutes to discuss the polls. Was turning one judgement call into three polls a good idea? The Department did not think so. Here is what the phrase means, where it comes from, "judgement" or "judgment", how it differs from "on second thought", "play it by ear" and "the ball is in your court", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.

The short answer

"A judgement call" is a decision you make from your own sense of what is best, because no rule settles it. "Short or long version for the newsletter?" "Judgement call. Your choice."

Where it comes from

It comes from referees and umpires, whose calls on close moments are made by eye when the rules leave room for opinion. The phrase now covers any decision that depends on someone's own view.

"Judgement" or "judgment"?

Both are correct. "Judgment call" is the usual American spelling; "judgement call" is common in British English. "Make a judgement call" is the usual way to use it.

Make the call, or ask the room?

Asking for views is often sensible. The Department's only advice is to ask once, then decide. A judgement call that waits for three polls has quietly become a meeting.

Honest, teasing or at work?

"A judgement call", "On second thought", "Play it by ear", "The ball is in your court"

How it reads in a text

Keep it light

  1. Ask for views once, then decide.
  2. Say briefly why you chose what you chose.
  3. Most judgement calls can be adjusted next week.

25 other ways to say "A judgement call"

Friendly

Casual

Mock official

Polite (work)

More from the Department

The Department of Doubt makes one judgement call every morning, then stamps it before noon. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own decision a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.

See also: what "On second thought" means, what "Play it by ear" means, and what "The ball is in your court" means.

Questions about "A judgement call"

What does "A judgement call" mean?

It means a decision you make from your own sense of what is best, because no rule or fact settles it. "There's no policy on it, so it's your judgement call."

Where does "judgement call" come from?

It comes from referees and umpires, whose "calls" on close moments are made by eye when the rules leave room for opinion. The phrase now covers any decision that depends on someone's own view.

Is it "judgement call" or "judgment call"?

Both are correct. "Judgment call" is the usual American spelling; "judgement call" is common in British English. The meaning is the same.

What does "make a judgement call" mean?

It means to decide something yourself, using your own sense of what is right, when there is no clear rule. "I had to make a judgement call and send it without the last figure."

What is the difference between "A judgement call" and "Play it by ear"?

"A judgement call" is one decision made with your own sense of what is best. "Play it by ear" means not planning ahead and deciding as things happen, often making several small judgement calls along the way.

What is a synonym for "A judgement call"?

Close phrases are "your call," "a matter of opinion," "up to you," "a discretionary decision," "a tough call" and "a case-by-case decision."

The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.

Meanwhile, at the DepartmentCase No. 0029 · today

Do you agree with the Department?

No votes yet.Be the first to agree or object.
Read the official note →