Department of DoubtForm 255: Source of rule, requested

"Says who?": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it

"Says who?" is what the Department of Doubt asks when a rule appears out of nowhere. The blue mug is officially yours? Says who? Socks must live in the top drawer? Says who? The thermostat stays at exactly twenty? Says who? Here is what the phrase means, whether it is rude, what it means in a chat, "says who?" vs "says you", how it differs from "if you say so", "I doubt it" and "pull the other one", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.

The short answer

"Says who?" means "Who decided that?" It questions the source of a rule or claim, and hints that you are not going along with it yet. "That's my chair now." "Says who?"

"Says who?" or "Says you"?

"Says who?" is the question: who made this rule? "Says you" is the comeback: that is just your opinion. And "says me" is the cheeky answer to both, which tends to keep the argument going rather than end it.

Curious, challenging or playful?

"Says who?", "If you say so", "I doubt it", "Pull the other one"

How it reads in a text

Keep it light

  1. Ask it with a smile, so it sounds curious rather than defiant.
  2. If they have a good source, accept it gracefully.
  3. Avoid it with someone who really does set the rules, like a manager in a meeting; "Where does that come from?" is gentler.

25 other ways to say "Says who?"

Friendly

Casual

Mock official

Polite (work)

More from the Department

The Department of Doubt asks "says who?" before it follows any new rule. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own idea a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.

See also: what "If you say so" means, what "I doubt it" means, and what "Pull the other one" means.

See also: what "Moving the goalposts" means.

Questions about "Says who?"

What does "Says who?" mean?

It means "Who decided that?" or "Where did that come from?" You say it when someone states a rule or a claim and you doubt that they, or anyone, has the authority to say so.

Is "Says who?" rude?

It can be. Said with a grin, it is playful pushback. Said sharply, it sounds like a challenge, as if you are refusing to accept the other person's say. Tone decides.

What does "Says who?" mean in a chat?

In a chat or text it usually means "prove it" or "who made that rule?" Adding "😏" or "lol" keeps it playful rather than combative.

What is the difference between "Says who?" and "Says you"?

"Says who?" asks where a claim or rule came from. "Says you" answers that question: it means "that is only your opinion," so it pushes back a little harder.

What is the difference between "Says who?" and "If you say so"?

"Says who?" challenges a claim out loud. "If you say so" lets the claim stand while quietly doubting it. One argues, the other shrugs.

How do you reply to "Says who?"

Give the source if there is one ("the instructions, page two"), or admit it is just your opinion. "Says me" is the cheeky answer, and it rarely ends the argument.

The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.

Meanwhile, at the DepartmentCase No. 0029 · today

Do you agree with the Department?

No votes yet.Be the first to agree or object.
Read the official note →