Department of DoubtForm 220: Suspiciously perfect plans

"Too good to be true": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it

"Too good to be true" is the Department of Doubt's first instinct, built in. A flat-pack wardrobe that builds itself in ten minutes, a group trip where everyone agrees on the dates first time, a houseplant labelled "impossible to forget about": the Department squints and looks for the catch. Here is what the phrase means, when it is delight and when it is suspicion, how it differs from "wishful thinking" and "not so fast", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.

The short answer

"Too good to be true" means "so perfect that there is probably a catch, or it isn't real." "Everyone agreed on the dates in one message?" "Sounds too good to be true." The longer version, "if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is", is everyday caution in one sentence.

Delighted, hopeful or suspicious?

"Too good to be true", "Wishful thinking", "Not so fast", "There's always a catch"

How it reads in a text

Keep it light

  1. Follow it with a real question, "what's the catch?", so it reads as curious, not cynical.
  2. Let good news be good news sometimes; not everything needs a squint.
  3. If the catch turns up, laugh about it together; if it never does, enjoy the rare win.

25 other ways to say "Too good to be true"

Friendly

Casual

Mock official

Polite (work)

More from the Department

The Department of Doubt treats every perfect plan as a puzzle with one piece missing, and it usually finds the piece. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own idea a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.

See also: what "Wishful thinking" means, what "Not so fast" means, and what "I'll believe it when I see it" means.

See also: what "What's the catch?" means.

Questions about "Too good to be true"

What does "Too good to be true" mean?

It means something sounds so perfect that it probably isn't real, or there is a catch hiding somewhere. "A flat-pack wardrobe that builds itself in ten minutes? Sounds too good to be true."

What does "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is" mean?

It is a piece of everyday caution: when something seems perfect, look for the catch before you get excited. The Department of Doubt has it framed above the stamp desk.

Can "Too good to be true" be a compliment?

Yes. "This weekend has been too good to be true" just means "this is wonderful, I can hardly believe it." The tone tells you whether it is delight or suspicion.

What is the difference between "Too good to be true" and "Wishful thinking"?

"Too good to be true" doubts something you have been offered or told. "Wishful thinking" doubts something you hope for yourself.

What is the difference between "Too good to be true" and "Not so fast"?

"Too good to be true" is the suspicion. "Not so fast" is the interruption that follows it, when you stop the plan to find the catch.

What does "Too good to be true" mean in a text?

"sounds too good to be true 🤨" is friendly suspicion. "too good to be true!!" with exclamation marks is delight. "too good to be true." with a full stop means "I don't believe it."

The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.

Meanwhile, at the DepartmentCase No. 0029 · today

Do you agree with the Department?

No votes yet.Be the first to agree or object.
Read the official note →