"Tall tale": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it
A "tall tale" is what the Department of Doubt calls a story that grows every time it is told. The spider in the shed was the size of a paperback. Then a bin lid. Then it waved. The queue at the post office took two hours, and someone brought a folding chair. The fish that got away is longer every summer. Here is what the phrase means, why it is "tall", what it means in literature and slang, whether it is a lie, how it differs from "far-fetched", "a likely story" and "pull the other one", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.
The short answer
A tall tale is a wildly exaggerated story that nobody quite believes. "The spider was as big as my hand, and it looked at me." "That's a tall tale."
Why "tall"?
In older English, "tall" could mean grand, boastful or hard to believe, as in "tall talk" or "a tall order." So a tall tale is a stretched, boastful story, not a long one.
Tall tales in storytelling
Folk storytelling has a whole tradition of tall tales: funny stories about larger-than-life heroes doing impossible things, told with a straight face as if they were true. The joke is that everyone knows they are not.
Affectionate, sceptical or teasing?
- "Our neighbour does love a tall tale." Affectionate: the stories are half the fun.
- "That sounds like a tall tale to me." Sceptical: I think it grew in the telling.
- "Another tall tale, is it? 😄" Teasing: here we go again.
- "Okay, it might have been a tall tale." Confessing: fine, the spider was smaller.
"Tall tale", "Far-fetched", "A likely story", "Pull the other one"
- Tall tale: an exaggerated story told for fun.
- Far-fetched: any idea that is hard to believe. See what "Far-fetched" means.
- A likely story: I don't believe your excuse. See what "A likely story" means.
- Pull the other one: I don't believe a word of it. See what "Pull the other one" means.
How it reads in a text
- "sounds like a tall tale 😄": friendly doubt.
- "the spider grows every time you tell this": same point, no idiom.
- "tall tale alert 🚨": teasing.
- "ok slight tall tale, it was medium": owning up.
Keep it light
- Enjoy the story first; a good tall tale is a gift.
- Call it out with a smile, not a fact-check.
- If you are telling one, let the exaggeration show; that is part of the fun.
25 other ways to say "Tall tale"
Friendly
- That's quite a story.
- It's grown a bit since last time.
- Bit of an exaggeration, maybe?
- Great story, slightly doubtful.
- What a story, honestly.
- Sounds like a stretch, but I love it.
- I think it got bigger in the telling.
Casual
- That's a whopper.
- Yarn alert.
- Spinning a yarn, are we?
- Embellished much?
- That one's been upgraded.
- The legend grows.
Mock official
- The Department of Doubt was told the shed spider was the size of a bin lid and waved. It did not think so, measured the spider, and found it roughly the size of a button.
- Notice: the story above has been measured and found taller than the facts allow.
- Form 265 records one spider, three versions of its size, and one very entertained audience.
Polite (work)
- That may be slightly overstated.
- I suspect the details have grown.
- Can we check the actual figures?
- That sounds a little exaggerated.
- Let's stick to what we can confirm.
- I'd want to see that verified.
- The account seems a bit embellished.
- Shall we separate the facts from the story?
- That's a memorable version of events.
More from the Department
The Department of Doubt enjoys a tall tale, but always measures the spider. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own idea a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.
See also: what "Far-fetched" means, what "A likely story" means, and what "Pull the other one" means.
Questions about "Tall tale"
What does "Tall tale" mean?
A tall tale is a story so exaggerated that nobody really believes it. It is usually told for fun, and the teller often knows the listener is not fooled.
Why is it called a "tall" tale?
In older English, "tall" could mean "grand," "boastful" or "hard to believe," as in "tall talk." So a tall tale is a boastful, stretched story, not a long one.
What does "tall tale" mean in literature?
In folk storytelling, a tall tale is a humorous story about a larger-than-life hero doing impossible things, told as if it were true. The fun is in the outrageous exaggeration.
What does "tall tale" mean in slang?
In everyday speech it simply means "an exaggerated story" or "a bit of a fib." "That fish was the size of a canoe? Sounds like a tall tale."
Is a tall tale the same as a lie?
Not quite. A lie is meant to deceive. A tall tale is usually meant to entertain, and both sides know it is stretched. Calling something a tall tale is gentler than calling it a lie.
What is the difference between "Tall tale" and "Far-fetched"?
"Tall tale" names the story itself. "Far-fetched" describes any idea, claim or plan that is hard to believe, whether or not it is a story.
The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.