"A likely story": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it
"A likely story" is what the Department of Doubt says when an excuse arrives a little too neatly. The cat knocked the plant pot over, and also moved the trowel to the sofa? A likely story. You were "just about to" fold the laundry when someone walked in? A likely story. The remote "fell" behind the radiator on its own? A likely story. Here is what the phrase means, why it means the opposite of what it says, whether it is rude, how it differs from "pull the other one", "you're having me on" and "says who?", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.
The short answer
"A likely story" means "I don't believe that excuse." It is sarcastic: the words say "likely," the tone says "invented." "I was just about to tidy up." "A likely story."
Why it means the opposite
The phrase works through irony. Said straight, "that's a likely story" would mean "that sounds believable." Said with raised eyebrows, it means the reverse: this is the kind of story people make up. Nearly everyone uses it the sarcastic way.
Teasing, sceptical or mock-stern?
- "Oh, a likely story 😏" Teasing: I know, and I don't really mind.
- "Hmm. A likely story." Sceptical: I am not convinced.
- "A likely story indeed." Mock-stern: said like a strict head teacher, for comic effect.
- "That's your story, is it?" Amused: go on, I'm listening, not believing.
"A likely story", "Pull the other one", "You're having me on", "Says who?"
- A likely story: I don't believe your excuse.
- Pull the other one: I don't believe a word of it. See what "Pull the other one" means.
- You're having me on: you must be joking. See what "You're having me on" means.
- Says who?: where did that come from? See what "Says who?" means.
How it reads in a text
- "a likely story 🙄": playful disbelief.
- "a likely story.": dry, not buying it.
- "likely story lol": casual, amused.
- "the cat did it, sure": same idea, no idiom.
Keep it light
- Use it for small, harmless excuses, where teasing is welcome.
- Smile, so it sounds like a joke rather than an accusation.
- If the excuse turns out to be true, admit it; the cat sometimes really did do it.
25 other ways to say "A likely story"
Friendly
- Oh, is that right?
- Sure, I believe you. Mostly.
- Hmm, nice story.
- That's your version, then?
- Okay, if you insist.
- Interesting timing.
- The cat, was it?
Casual
- Oh, naturally.
- Tell me another.
- Convenient, that.
- Mm-hm, totally.
- Sounds made up, but go on.
- Uh-huh. Sure.
Mock official
- The Department of Doubt was told the cat moved the trowel to the sofa. It did not think so, interviewed the cat, and recorded "no comment" as the cat's full statement.
- Notice: the excuse above has been logged, reviewed, and filed under fiction.
- Form 264 records one plant pot, one innocent-looking cat, and one story nobody believes.
Polite (work)
- I'd like to understand what happened.
- Could you walk me through that?
- That doesn't quite add up for me.
- Can you help me see how that happened?
- I'm not sure that fully explains it.
- Let's check the details on that.
- Is there more context I'm missing?
- That seems unusual; can we look into it?
- I'd want to verify that before we move on.
More from the Department
The Department of Doubt has heard every excuse, and believed very few. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own idea a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.
See also: what "Pull the other one" means, what "You're having me on" means, and what "Says who?" means.
Questions about "A likely story"
What does "A likely story" mean?
It is sarcastic. It means "I don't believe that for a second." When someone gives an excuse that sounds made up, "a likely story" says it is actually a very unlikely one.
Why does "A likely story" mean the opposite?
Because it is said with irony. The words say "that sounds likely," but the tone says "that sounds invented." Without the sarcastic tone, the phrase would make little sense in conversation.
Is "A likely story" rude?
It can be, because it suggests someone is not telling the truth. Among friends and family it is usually playful teasing. With someone you do not know well, it can sound like an accusation.
What is the difference between "A likely story" and "Pull the other one"?
Both doubt what you have been told. "A likely story" usually answers an excuse. "Pull the other one" answers a claim or a wind-up, and suggests someone is trying to fool you.
What is a synonym for "A likely story"?
Close phrases are "yeah, sure," "of course it did," "pull the other one" and "tell me another." At work, "I'd like to understand what happened" is the polite version.
What does "A likely story" mean in a text?
"a likely story 🙄" is playful disbelief. "a likely story." with a full stop is drier, as if you are not buying it and not pretending to.
The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.