Department of DoubtForm 247: Suspected wind-up

"You're having me on": what it means, and 25 other ways to say it

"You're having me on" is what the Department of Doubt says when news sounds a little too surprising. The bus was early? You're having me on. The plant grew a metre overnight? You're having me on. Someone actually put the lid back on the glue? You're having me on. Here is what the phrase means, how British "having me on" compares with American "putting me on", how it differs from "pull the other one", "far-fetched" and "nice try", how it reads in a text, and 25 other ways to say it.

The short answer

"You're having me on" means "you're joking, that can't be true." It is a friendly reaction to news that sounds like a wind-up. "The meeting's been cancelled and we can all go early." "You're having me on."

"Having me on" or "putting me on"?

Same meaning, different side of the ocean. "You're having me on" is mainly British and Irish. "You're putting me on" is mainly American. Both come from the idea of fooling someone for fun, and both work as a question too: "Are you having me on?"

Amused or suspicious?

"You're having me on", "Pull the other one", "Far-fetched", "Nice try"

How it reads in a text

Keep it light

  1. Smile when you say it, so it sounds like surprise and not an accusation.
  2. If the news is true, switch quickly to "no way, that's brilliant".
  3. If you were the one joking, own up fast: a wind-up is funniest when it ends quickly.

25 other ways to say "You're having me on"

Friendly

Casual

Mock official

Polite (work)

More from the Department

The Department of Doubt assumes every surprising announcement is a wind-up until proven otherwise. See today's case, browse the archive, or give your own idea a stamp in Stamp Anything. More phrase guides are in all guides.

See also: what "Pull the other one" means, what "Far-fetched" means, and what "Nice try" means.

See also: what "Come again?" means.

Questions about "You're having me on"

What does "You're having me on" mean?

It means "you're joking" or "you're teasing me, that can't be true." You say it when something sounds so surprising that you suspect a wind-up.

What does "You're putting me on" mean?

It is the American version of the same idea: "you're kidding me." "Having me on" is mostly British and Irish; "putting me on" is mostly American. Both mean you think the other person is joking.

Is "You're having me on" a question?

It can be either. As a statement it says "I don't believe you." As a question, "Are you having me on?", it genuinely asks whether the other person is joking.

What is the difference between "You're having me on" and "Pull the other one"?

They mean nearly the same. "You're having me on" can be honest surprise, even when the news turns out to be true. "Pull the other one" is firmer: you are sure it is a joke.

Is "You're having me on" rude?

No. It is friendly and informal. It doubts the story, not the person, and is often said with a laugh. Said flatly to a stranger, it can sound like you think they are lying.

What does "You're having me on" mean in a text?

"you're having me on 😂" is amused disbelief. "are you having me on??" is a real question. "you're having me on. really?" means you are starting to believe it.

The Department of Doubt is satire, but this page is a plain guide to an English phrase. See the satire notice.

Meanwhile, at the DepartmentCase No. 0029 · today

Do you agree with the Department?

No votes yet.Be the first to agree or object.
Read the official note →